Taste vs taste
beta-challenger vs beta-critic
Compared across every ranking each creator has published
The answer
They agree 43% of the time across 7 items they've both ranked.
4Both rank in a top five
5Biggest rank gap
Both put these in a top 5: Nioh 2 · Hollow Knight · Sekiro: Shadows Die Twice · Dark Souls III
Biggest disagreements
Lies of P beta-challenger #7 in The soulslikes, in order · beta-critic #2 in Soulslike action-RPGs, ranked
Bloodborne beta-challenger #3 in The soulslikes, in order · beta-critic #6 in Soulslike action-RPGs, ranked
Elden Ring beta-challenger #6 in The soulslikes, in order · beta-critic #3 in Soulslike action-RPGs, ranked
Hollow Knight beta-challenger #2 in The soulslikes, in order · beta-critic #3 in Metroidvanias, top to bottom
Sekiro: Shadows Die Twice beta-challenger #4 in The soulslikes, in order · beta-critic #5 in Soulslike action-RPGs, ranked
Where does your taste land?Build your own ranking and turn vague agreement into an exact order.